Michael Mann, Creator of the ‘Hockey Stick’ Climate Graph, Is Held in Contempt of Court for Withholding Scientific Evidence

image_pdfimage_print
British Colombia: After six years, the libel lawsuit filed by Michael Mann, the climate scientist who created the ‘hockey stick’ climate model and graph, is finally coming to an end. The lawsuit was against Tim Ball, a retired professor at the University of Winnipeg, for saying that the data used by Mann was fraudulent and that he should be in the state pen instead of Penn State. Mann claimed that this was defamation of character. The court, however, asked Mann to prove that his data was not fraudulent and asked for it to be made available for inspection. When Mann refused, he was in contempt of a court order, and that likely will lead to the collapse of his case against Professor Ball. Dr. Ball is expected to instruct his attorneys to ask for punitive court action, including a ruling that Mann did act with criminal intent when using public funds to commit climate-data fraud. [Professor Ball’s debunking of Global Warming soon will be broadcast on the Internet along with thirteen other experts who participated in a conference, sponsored by Freedom Force International, called Global Warming, An Inconvenient Lie. To be advised of the date and time of this free broadcast, click here.]   –GEG

Penn State climate scientist, Michael ‘hockey stick’ Mann commits contempt of court in the ‘climate science trial of the century.’ Prominent alarmist shockingly defies judge and refuses to surrender data for open court examination. Only possible outcome: Mann’s humiliation, defeat and likely criminal investigation in the U.S.

The defendant in the libel trial, the 79-year-old Canadian climatologist, Dr Tim Ball (above, right) is expected to instruct his British Columbia attorneys to trigger mandatory punitive court sanctions, including a ruling that Mann did act with criminal intent when using public funds to commit climate data fraud. Mann’s imminent defeat is set to send shock waves worldwide within the climate science community as the outcome will be both a legal and scientific vindication of U.S. President Donald Trump’s claims that climate scare stories are a “hoax.”

As can be seen from the graphs below; Mann’s cherry-picked version of science makes the Medieval Warm Period (MWP) disappear and shows a pronounced upward ‘tick’ in the late 20th century (the blade of his ‘hockey stick’). But below that, Ball’s graph, using more reliable and widely available public data, shows a much warmer MWP, with temperatures hotter than today, and showing current temperatures well within natural variation.

Michael Mann, who chose to file what many consider to be a cynical SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation) libel suit in the British Columbia Supreme Court, Vancouver six long years ago, has astonished legal experts by refusing to comply with the court direction to hand over all his disputed graph’s data. Mann’s iconic hockey stick has been relied upon by the UN’s IPCC and western governments as crucial evidence for the science of ‘man-made global warming.’

As first reported in Principia Scientific International (February 1, 2017), the defendant in the case, Canadian climatologist Dr. Tim Ball, had won “concessions” against Mann, but at the time the details were kept confidential, pending Mann’s response.

The negative and unresponsive actions of Dr Mann and his lawyer, Roger McConchie, are expected to infuriate the judge and be the signal for the collapse of Mann’s multi-million dollar libel suit against Dr Ball. It will be music to the ears of so-called ‘climate deniers’ like President Donald Trump and his EPA Chief, Scott Pruitt.

As Dr Ball explains:

“Michael Mann moved for an adjournment of the trial scheduled for February 20, 2017. We had little choice because Canadian courts always grant adjournments before a trial in their belief that an out of court settlement is preferable. We agreed to an adjournment with conditions. The major one was that he [Mann] produce all documents including computer codes by February 20th, 2017. He failed to meet the deadline.”

Punishment for Civil Contempt

Mann’s now proven contempt of court means Ball is entitled to have the court serve upon Mann the fullest punishment. Contempt sanctions could reasonably include the judge ruling that Dr. Ball’s statement that Mann “belongs in the state pen, not Penn. State’ is a precise and true statement of fact. This is because under Canada’s unique ‘Truth Defense’, Mann is now proven to have wilfully hidden his data, so the court may rule he hid it because it is fake. As such, the court must then dismiss Mann’s entire libel suit with costs awarded to Ball and his team.

The spectacular rise and fall of climate alarmism’s former golden boy is a courtroom battle with even more ramifications than the infamous Scopes Monkey Trial of 1925. To much fanfare at the time, Mann had sued Ball for daring to publish the damning comment that Mann “belongs in the state pen, not Penn. State.” Dr Ball brilliantly backed up his exposure of the elaborate international money-making global warming scam in his astonishing book, ‘The Deliberate Corruption of Climate Science‘.

In his books, articles, radio and television appearances, Dr. Ball has been resolute in his generation-long war against those who corrupted the field of science to which he had selflessly dedicated his life. Now aged 79, Ball is on the cusp of utter vindication. Despite the stresses and strains on himself and his family, Tim has stood at the forefront of those scientists demanding more openness and transparency from government-funded researchers.

As Ball explains:

“We believe he [Mann] withheld on the basis of a US court ruling that it was all his intellectual property. This ruling was made despite the fact the US taxpayer paid for the research and the research results were used as the basis of literally earth-shattering policies on energy and environment. The problem for him is that the Canadian court holds that you cannot withhold documents that are central to your charge of defamation regardless of the US ruling.”

Likely Repercussions for Science & Climate Policy

A bitter and embarrassing defeat for the self-styled ‘Nobel Prize winner’ who acted as if he was the epitome of virtue, this outcome shames not only Michael Mann, but puts the climate science community in crisis. Many hundreds of peer-reviewed papers cite Mann’s work, which is now effectively junked. Despite having deep-pocketed backers willing and able to feed his ego as a publicity-seeking mouthpiece against skeptics, Mann’s credibility as a champion of environmentalism is in tatters.

But it gets worse for the litigious Penn State professor. Close behind Dr Ball is celebrated writer Mark Steyn. Steyn also defends himself against another one of Mann’s SLAPP suits – this time in Washington DC. Steyn boldly claims Mann “has perverted the norms of science on an industrial scale.” Esteemed American climate scientist, Dr Judith Curry, has submitted to the court an Amicus Curiae legal brief exposing Mann. The world can now see that his six-year legal gambit to silence his most effective critics and chill scientific debate has spectacularly backfired.

But at a time of much clamor about ‘fake news,’ it seems climate scare stories will have a new angle now that the United States has officially stepped back from the Paris Climate Treaty. President Trump was elected on a mandate to weed out climate fraud so his supporters will point to this legal outcome as vindication for a full purge. It makes a mockery of statements made by Mann last February when PSI’s Hans Schreuder and John O’Sullivan publicly backed their colleague, Dr Ball and endorsed the revelations in his book. Mann reacted by moaning:

“It is difficult to keep up with this dizzying ongoing assault on science.”

The perpetrator of the biggest criminal “assault on science” has now become clear: Dr Mann, utterly damned by his contempt of the court order to show his dodgy data.

There can be little doubt that upon the BC Supreme Court ruling that Mann did commit data fraud, over in Washington DC, the EPA’s Scott Pruitt will feel intense pressure from skeptics to initiate a full investigation into Mann, his university and all those conspiring to perpetuate a trillion-dollar carbon tax-raising sting on taxpayers.

Read full article here…

Visit our Classified ads.

Check out our Classified ads at the bottom of this page.

Recent stories & commentary

Uncategorized

Company Owned by Trump’s Son-In-Law Faces Federal Grand Jury Subpoena

April 23, 2018 Breitbart 0

New York: Federal prosecutors approved subpoenas to Kushner Companies based on a report by AP that found the real estate company repeatedly filed forms with the New York City Department of Buildings claiming they owned no rent-controlled apartment units while actually possessing hundreds of such units. The false filings allowed Kushner Companies to raise rents and, in turn, sell those buildings at a great profit two years later. […]

Uncategorized

Pay Dirt: Obama’s DOJ Had No Evidence to Justify Opening Russia Investigation

April 23, 2018 Fox News 0

Congress finally received the ‘electronic communication’, which is the original reason why counterintelligence spied on the Trump campaign alleging they colluded with Russia, but no official intelligence was used to open the investigation, which indicates the investigation was illegal. Congress is investigating the US State Department because its info was leaked to the FBI. Four of Comey’s memos were classified and he laundered them through a friend who leaked them to the New York Times in order to open a special counsel investigation- also illegal. […]

Politics

WikiLeaks Says It Will Have “Amazing Fun” in Countering DNC Lawsuit

April 23, 2018 ZeroHedge 0

The DNC filed a lawsuit alleging the Trump campaign, the Russian government, and WikiLeaks conspired to interfere in the 2016 presidential campaign to tip the election in favor of Donald Trump. The purpose of the lawsuit is to motivate donors and voters on the far left. WikiLeaks has vowed to counter-sue and is delighted at the prospect of opening discovery on the DNC while Trump expressed interest in getting hold of the DNC servers that the FBI was never allowed to inspect. […]

Money

Europe’s Largest Bank to Stop Funding Coal Plants and Arctic Drilling

April 23, 2018 Daily Caller 0

Europe’s largest bank, HSBC, announced it would no longer finance coal power plants, oil sands projects in Canada and offshore drilling in the Arctic, in order to comply with the Paris Treaty. Other banks that have also refused to invest in coal and oil companies include ING, BNP Paribas and BBVA, due to pressure from environmentalists, who are backed by globalists interested in limiting access to energy. […]

Politics

Leftist Anti-Gun Professor Charged with Spraying Fake Blood on Home of NRA Lobbyist

April 23, 2018 The Hill 0

Virginia: Anti-gun leftists ramp up the pressure, weaponizing intimidation and shame, by confronting their targets at their homes. Chris Cox, a lobbyist for the NRA, said that the extremists sprayed fake blood on his home, protest his home with a poster of a dead child, created a website mimicking his wife’s business, and distributed flyers outside of his wife’s interior design business. The leftist academia is behind much of the heightened protests and criminal activity, including University of Nebraska-Lincoln professor Patricia Hill, who was arrested for allegedly spraying the fake blood on the Cox’s home on two occasions. […]

Freedom

North Korea State Media Announced Nuclear Program Shutdown

April 22, 2018 Breitbart 0

North Korean dictator Kim Jong-un announced he will halt nuclear and missile tests in his country and will shut down a nuclear test site as a show of good faith. It is unknown if the tests will conclude permanently. Kim Jong-un will meet with the leader of South Korea to officially end the Korean war. They will discuss the denuclearization of the Korean peninsula, and US presence on the site. […]

Kakistocracy

Rand Paul Questions Syria Gas Attack and New Evidence It Was a False Flag Hoax

April 20, 2018 RT 2

A boy who was featured in the viral video that showed children being showered with water because of a chemical attack expressed confusion over why he was grabbed and had water poured over him. An Arabic-speaking British investigative journalist interviewed locals in Douma who reported that there was no chemical attack. Rand Paul questioned the attack and told CNN’s Wolf Blitzer that if Assad did it, he has to be the stupidest dictator on the planet because Assad is winning the war. […]

Freedom

NY Governor Cuomo Warns Banks and Insurance Companies to Drop the NRA and Gun Industry

April 20, 2018 Daily Caller 0

New York: Governor Andrew Cuomo is trying pressure state banks and insurance companies from doing business with the NRA and firearms manufacturers. He sent a letter urging “all insurance companies and banks doing business in New York to join the companies that have already discontinued their arrangements with the NRA, gun industry, or other promoters of guns,” stopping just short of threats and punishment. […]

Kakistocracy

Secretive Leftist Donors List Medicare for All, Free College and Reparations as Goals for 2022

April 20, 2018 Daily Caller 0

The Democracy Alliance, a top left-wing donor group, listed Medicare for all, free college and reparations for black Americans on its list of goals for 2022. The Democracy Alliance is a secretive, network of over 100 progressive donors who spend at least $200,000 per year on groups the Democracy Alliance vets and recommends. Members of the covert group include George Soros, Tom Steyer, Norman Lear, Rob Reiner, Drummond Pike, founder of the Tides Foundation, and Rob Stein, a former Clinton Treasury official. […]

Uncategorized

Congress Receives James Comey’s Memos that Show that He Lied

April 20, 2018 Fox News 0

Congressman Chris Stewart said that Comey was dishonest with Trump from the beginning because he should have refuted the dossier, and he failed to tell the President that the unverified document was fiction and was funded by the DNC and Hillary Clinton. Comey also told Trump that he was not a leaker, however, he did leak his memos to the press. […]

Globalism

Sweden: Shootings Are So Common, the Media Doesn’t Bother to Report Them

April 19, 2018 Politico 0

Sweden: Grenade attacks have become a daily part of life, shooting is common, 43% of rapes are against children, and Muslim terror attacks are rising. There are 62 “no-go” zones that are dominated by gangs where the police fear to go, ambulances cannot respond to emergencies, and fire engines are attacked. Hand grenades sell for about $30, and are used by gangs to warn police to get out. Elections will be held September and the liberals may be forced out by conservatives. […]

Cartoon Commentary

Classifieds

For classified advertising rates and terms, click here. The appearance of ads on this site does not signify endorsement by the publisher. We do not attempt to verify the accuracy of statements made therein or vouch for the integrity of advertisers. However, we will investigate complaints from readers and remove any message we find to be misleading or that promotes anything fraudulent, illegal, or unethical.

Leave a Reply

10 Comments on "Michael Mann, Creator of the ‘Hockey Stick’ Climate Graph, Is Held in Contempt of Court for Withholding Scientific Evidence"

avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Patricia P Tursi
Guest

Good News.

trackback
Michael Mann, Creator of the ‘Hockey Stick’ Climate Graph, Is Held in Contempt of Court for Withholding Scientific Evidence – Life, Death and all between

[…] Source: Michael Mann, Creator of the ‘Hockey Stick’ Climate Graph, Is Held in Contempt of Court for With… […]

trackback
Three 7-7-17 articles that indicate “The Cabal Agenda is Falling Apart”… Syria ceasefire US/Russia deal, No more “Hockey stick climate graph”, and a “HUGE Pedophile Sting” | Kauilapele's Blog

[…] Michael Mann, Creator of the ‘Hockey Stick’ Climate Graph, Is Held in Contempt of Court for With… (NeedtoKnow.news, 7-7-17) […]

trackback
All “Global Warming” Manipulated Figures” (Peer-Review). Incredible Fraud of “Climate Gurus” Exposed – and Concealed by Media | NEW.EURO-MED.DK

[…] Edward Griffin 7 July 2017: After six years, the libel lawsuit filed by Michael Mann, the  climate “scientist” who created the ‘hockey stick’ climate model and graph, is finally coming to an end. The lawsuit was against Tim Ball, a retired professor at the University of Winnipeg, for saying that the data used by Mann was fraudulent and that he should be in the state pen instead of Penn State. Mann claimed that this was defamation of character. […]

trackback
”Alle “Erderwärmung” manipulierte Zahlen” (Peer-Artikel). Unglaublicher Betrug der “Klima-Gurus” enthüllt – und von Medien verschwiegen. | NEW.EURO-MED.DK

[…] Edward Griffin 7 July 2017:  Nach sechs Jahren ist die von Michael Mann, dem “Klimawissenschaftler”, der das “Hockey-Stab” -Klima- Grafik erstellt hat, eingereichte Verleumdungsklage  endlich zu Ende. Die Klage war gegen Tim Ball, ein pensionierter Professor an der Universität von Winnipeg, um zu sagen, dass die von Mann benutzten Daten betrügerisch seien und dass er in der Staatspenne (hier = Gefängnis) statt im Penn Staat (Pennsylvanien) sein sollte. Mann behauptete, dass dies  Verleumdung des Charakters sei. […]

trackback
”Alle “Erderwärmung” manipulierte Zahlen” (Peer-Artikel). Unglaublicher Betrug der “Klima-Gurus” enthüllt – und von Medien verschwiegen. | Der Honigmann sagt...

[…] Edward Griffin 7 July 2017:  Nach sechs Jahren ist die von Michael Mann, dem “Klimawissenschaftler”, der das “Hockey-Stab” -Klima- Grafik erstellt hat, eingereichte Verleumdungsklage  endlich zu Ende. Die Klage war gegen Tim Ball, ein pensionierter Professor an der Universität von Winnipeg, um zu sagen, dass die von Mann benutzten Daten betrügerisch seien und dass er in der Staatspenne (hier = Gefängnis) statt im Penn Staat (Pennsylvanien) sein sollte. Mann behauptete, dass dies  Verleumdung des Charakters sei. […]

Dan Aldridge
Guest
Ernest
Guest

Ball wanted the raw data and all the computer codes to see how the data was massaged to make the Medieval Warm Period and the Little Ice Age disappear.

Follow the debate here: https://www.thenewamerican.com/usnews/item/26431-controversy-in-the-climate-science-trial-of-the-century

trackback
New Study: No Ocean Warming the last 50 Years. House of Cards of Global Warmis Collapsing – Warmist Lies getting More and More Grotesque | NEW.EURO-MED.DK

[…] Arch fraudster Michael Mann (Climategate scandal and “hockey stick”) had the upper graph of historical global temperatures. Serious Tim Ball has the lower graph (Edward Griffin 7 July 2017). […]