San Francisco Has Made the ‘Homeless’ A Profitable Industry

Youtube personality Colion Noir traveled to San Francisco, one of the most expensive cities in the country, and exposed expansion of the homelessness problem by dependency on the government that has created an industry around vagrancy. San Francisco has 8 city departments that issue over 400 contracts to about 75 private organizations that have no unifying oversight to assist its homeless population of 7,500 people. Big tech companies are pushing out the middle class and lower middle class population.
Residents in the pricey South Beach neighborhood, where a 225-bed homeless shelter “Navigation Center” is planned, are raising money to stop the project as it is a threat to safety and tourism, and they don’t want it “in their backyard.” They have raised $94,000 to fight the proposal while supporters of the shelter, including tech CEOs from Salesforce and Twitter, have raised about $168,000. A resident noted that these tech giants who support the shelter do not live in the area and don’t want it in their backyard, either.

The prospect of a 225-bed shelter in San Francisco’s trendy South Beach neighborhood has kicked off a bitter fundraising battle between area residents who say homeless people should be helped somewhere else and supporters who say no one should be sleeping on the streets.

To some residents in the pricey and touristy neighborhood along the Embarcadero, plans to build a new homeless shelter amid expensive apartment towers threaten public safety and tourism. To supporters of the proposal, that opposition reflects NIMBYism pure and simple.

Mayor London Breed’s planned 225-bed shelter near the Bay Bridge would become the city’s seventh “Navigation Center.” Unlike many basic overnight shelters, the centers have all-hours staff and no curfew. Services and referrals related to health care and housing are available. Extended stays are possible.

But as San Francisco grapples with a highly visible homelessness crisis featuring sidewalks littered with human waste and needles, the initiative has sparked dueling GoFundMe efforts for and against the shelter.

Days after concerned residents launched a “Safe Embarcadero for All” GoFundMe campaign last month to drum up cash for a potential legal fight, a former Google employee launched a GoFundMe counter-attack, the “SAFER Embarcadero for ALL” campaign, which has attracted big donations from some of the city’s most prominent tech CEOs. As of midday Friday, supporters of the shelter had raised about $168,000 compared with about $94,000 amassed by opponents.

“When you’re living outside, it’s so dangerous, so cold, there’s so many reasons it’s bad,” said ex-Googler William Fitzgerald, who started the SAFER campaign to raise money for the city’s Coalition on Homelessness. “I’m just supportive of housing in general. It shouldn’t be that radical of an idea. San Francisco has chosen the route of at least trying to get people on a first step toward housing.”

That step, in this case, is in the wrong place, said Wallace Lee, an organizer of the opposition campaign who lives a block-and-a-half from the proposed shelter site with his wife and toddler daughter.

“My biggest concern is public safety,” said Lee, a 34-year-old stay-at-home dad, who also worries about the prospect of used needles. “Gathering a lot of people, some of whom will cause property crime and some violent crime, in an area that’s densely populated and with a lot of children and a lot of elderly is not a good idea. I can hardly imagine a worse area to put a Navigation Center with so many residents and tourists and workers walking by every day.

“It’s not that we don’t want to see homelessness — it’s that we don’t want the effects of Navigation Centers.”

He cited a Vancouver, Canada, study that concluded property crime rates increased by 56 percent within 110 yards of winter-only shelters in that city. However, that study also found crime started dissipating beyond about a quarter-mile from a shelter.

Lee said he and other opponents of the proposed Navigation Center support efforts to resolve San Francisco’s homelessness crisis — 7,500 unhoused residents in 2017, according to the city’s official count — by putting Navigation Centers in empty lots in thinly populated areas of the city.

To Fitzgerald, the backlash against an Embarcadero shelter is “straight-up NIMBYism.”

“This idea that they want housing solutions for people but just not in their neighborhood, I just don’t think it’s an honest argument,” Fitzgerald said.

But Lee puts the NIMBY label on the tech honchos leading donations in favor of the shelter. The fundraising campaign in favor of the new shelter has drawn support from CEOs Marc Benioff of Salesforce, Jack Dorsey of Twitter and Square, Nat Friedman of GitHub, and Twilio’s Jeff Lawson. Dorsey kicked in $25,000, with the other three each contributing $10,000.

Read full article here…

Visit our Classified ads.

Check out our Classified ads at the bottom of this page.

Recent stories & commentary


Joe Biden Names Kamala Harris as His Running Mate for Vice President

August 12, 2020 BBC 2

Harris, in order to appeal to the radical left, came out in favor of free college education, the Green New Deal environmental program, universal healthcare and free healthcare for illegal immigrants. Biden’s deteriorating mental state makes it likely his VP could become president if Democrats win.


Chaos, Looting and Vandalism in Chicago

August 11, 2020 ZeroHedge 0

Thirteen police officers were injured, and a security guard and a civilian also were struck by gunfire. The Mayor and Chief of Police responded with stern words against the rioters. [Now we shall see what their actions are.]


Seattle City Council Approves Plan to Defund Police. Goodbye Seattle.

August 11, 2020 Fox News 0

The police department’s $400 million budget was cut by about $3 million. Council member Kshama Sawant was the sole “no” vote because she felt the proposals didn’t go far enough. Riots broke out and Amazon, Whole Foods, and a Chase Bank were vandalized. Police Chief Carmen Best has resigned from her position.

GEG Commentary

Portland Mayor Accuses Rioters of ‘Attempting To Commit Murder’

August 10, 2020 ZeroHedge 2

It is possible that Trump may be the preferred candidate of the deep state because he will have far more support of the American people than Biden would when the President declares martial law. That IS the end game of the deep state. Look up the definition of ‘controlled opposition’ and read it twice.


For classified advertising rates and terms, click here. The appearance of ads on this site does not signify endorsement by the publisher. We do not attempt to verify the accuracy of statements made therein or vouch for the integrity of advertisers. However, we will investigate complaints from readers and remove any message we find to be misleading or that promotes anything fraudulent, illegal, or unethical.

Notify of
1 Comment
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
San Francisco Exposed: Homelessness Has Become an Industry. Shelter Plan Sparks ‘Not In My Backyard’ (NIMBY) Row | WeAreChangeTV.US
1 year ago

[…] 10, 2019 Marinij No Comments This post was originally published on this […]